Making Information Useful

Entries categorized as ‘Problems’

A Black Hole Between Data and Knowledge

April 16, 2009 · Leave a Comment

A post at The Infography Manifesto Blog sums up the problem quite well.  According to this post, a “person dealing with information overload has difficulty finding information that’s relevant to help them make decisions.”  It also defined information anxiety as: A condition “produced by the ever widening gap between what we understand and what we think we should understand… the black hole between data and knowledge… when information doesn’t tell us what we want or need to know.

A one-post blog by the same author of The Infography Manifesto aptly states that there are “175,000 new blogs created every day … and this is one of them.”

This has been said a thousand times in a thousand ways, but it resonates with me every time I read things like this.  It also motivates me to spend time researching potential solutions to this problem.

My favorite part of the blog posting referenced in the first paragraph is a quote from Einstein stating that “we cannot solve problems with the same thinking we used when we created them.”  That is certainly true, and I have been reading about – and experimenting with – some fresh ideas.  I plan to write more about this in future posts.

Categories: Problems

Too much is not useful, even for animals

March 27, 2009 · Leave a Comment

According to scientists, people choose what they know when inundated with too much information.  This makes sense to me.  When faced with too much information, it is easier to go with something you are already familiar with than to sort through all the possible options.  I know that I tend to go back to the same  web site for travel information (www.tripadvisor.com) even though I know there are a lot of other good options out there.  It turns out that people are not alone.  Animals exhibit the same behavior.  An article at insciences.org claims that animals stick with food choices that they know, even when provided with food sources of identical nutritional value.  They may stick with a food source even when it is scare and other, more plentiful, options exist.

So how does this relate to making information useful?  I believe it adds credibility to the argument that too much information is not useful.  Information is only useful when it is filtered down to that which is most relevant.  Once this is done, humans (and apparently most animals) can choose the most optimal option.

The problem is that there is not much out there to help us filter information, so of course, we revert back to what we already know.  The result is that we unfortunately miss out on potentially better information.  That is not very useful.

Update 3/30/09 – Here is a link to a better article

Categories: Problems
Tagged:

The Problem: What Makes Information Useless?

March 22, 2009 · Leave a Comment

It is time to get this blog going. Before I spend time writing about how to make information more useful (i.e. solutions), I would like to capture some thoughts on the problems that cause information NOT to be useful (useless).

Here are five problems (please leave me a comment if you have some others):

#1 – Not Enough Information

In order for information to be useful, it must be complete enough to allow conclusions to be reached or decisions to be made. There are times when there just isn’t enough information available. Thankfully, this is rather rare in this day in age (unless we are doing new research). I won’t spend much time writing about this problem.

#2 – Information Overload

Information is not useful when there is so much of it that you can’t find what is really important in a given context. This is the complete inverse of problem #1, yet it has become a much bigger problem in the modern “internet age”. In fact, it has been said that information overload costs the economy $650 Billion per year.

The problem of information is a relatively recent phenomenon, but there were some that saw this coming. Here is a great 1971 quote from Herbert Simon that was recently discussed on the Knowledge Jolt With Jack weblog:

“…in an information-rich world, the wealth of information means a dearth of something else: a scarcity of whatever it is that information consumes. What information consumes is rather obvious: it consumes the attention of its recipients. Hence a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention and a need to allocate that attention efficiently among the overabundance of information sources that might consume it” (Simon, 1971, Designing Organizations for an Information-Rich World, p 40-41.).”

Information Overload is a big problem for me and I plan to write quite a bit about it.

#3 – Poor Communication

Sometimes good information is available, but it is not communicated well and becomes useless as a result. This is a huge topic in itself, but I will simply define the problem of poor communication as “useless information that would have otherwise been useful, had it been communicated better”. I realize that definition doesn’t say a whole lot, but I’ll follow up with additional posts on this topic to break it down further.

#4 – Inaccessible Information

How many times have you been in a situation where you need some information to make a decision – and you know that this information exists – but you don’t have access to it? If information isn’t accessible to you, it isn’t useful.

#5 – Wrong Information

Information may sometimes have all the characteristics of useful information except for one thing – it’s FALSE! False information, or misinformation, is not useful because it is misleading. This can be the most dangerous because it may lead to bad decisions.

#6 – Incomplete or Irrelevant Information

Incomplete and Irrelevant information can be worse than no information. [NEEDS TO BE FINISHED]

Categories: Problems